Inside Out: Oscar for originality?

Sometimes the smallest niggles can bug one the most. So it was when I saw an article on Slate that wanted to award Inside Out the discontinued Oscar for Best Original Story.

The Best Original Story Oscar existed between 1928 and 1956 to honor the writers who came up with the idea or treatment for a film but may or may not have actually written the script. This year’s award goes to Pete Docter and Ronnie Del Carmen for Inside Out, which featured one of the most original narratives in recent memory.

When I first heard about Inside Out I was quite happy that there was an original story. It seems that these days nearly everything is a sequel, a reboot or an adaptation. Comic book adaptations are the best example right now but just look at the Best Picture nominations for the Oscars.

The Revenant: Based on a book based on real events.

The Big Short: Based on a book about real events.

Bridge of Spies: Based on real events.

The Martian: Based on a book.

Room: Based on a book.

Spotlight: Based on real events.

Brooklyn: Based on a book.

Mad Max: Fury Road: Sequel.

There isn’t a single original story there! At best, it’s adapting something that happened in real life into a movie.But, most of them are based off of books.

In any case, when I was reading, I couldn’t help but remember that Inside Out is actually very similar to a 2013 animated short entitled Brain Divided, with the short’s two characters having the same colour scheme as two characters from Inside Out. Although, to be fair, red and blue are not unlikely to show up as opposites.

But, as Wikipedia and comments on that short point out, production on Inside Out starting in 2009, four years before Brain Divided. What it definitely did not start before was The Numskulls, a comic strip that originally ran from 1962 until 1969. But apparently, it’s been rebooted and is still ongoing.


So, Inside Out is certainly not completely original, but I guess we could draw a distinction between conceptual originality and narrative originality. The Slate article did specify narrative originality, in which case Inside Out is good. At least I assume so, I want to watch it but I haven’t had the opportunity yet. Conceptually, it’s not original but compared to many other films that get attention, it’s so far in the distance that they can’t even see its dust.

On hiatus

By this point, it’s probably fairly obvious that this blog is on hiatus. I’m afraid I just don’t have the time to create new posts at the moment. It’s not a shortage of ideas – as I have had several, some which would’ve been really cool to put together – but just a question of what I can manage at the moment. I don’t want to just leave it hanging empty, so, this post will serve as a thank you to everyone that has read my blog and a promise to bring back to life when I have the time available.

My Viennese library

It’s not nearly as impressive as what I had back in Cape Town (Books were too big and heavy to take with me.) but it’s slowly growing.

My Viennese library

My Viennese library

I got I Wish I’d Made You Angry Earlier for free! During the introductory talk by the campus librarian, he gave us a short challenge to complete and the person that found the answer first would get a book. (In the end I believe he actually gave away two books because the replies were so close together.) It was just a simple task to look up the number that specified where the book could be found in the library. The library, and a nearby research lab, is named after Max Perutz, who was born in Austria, making the book a suitable prize.

I only got Faith Vs Fact a few days ago but I’m quite excited. It was actually almost 3 weeks later than Amazon originally promised but I’ll try to forgive them for that. It’s Jerry Coyne’s latest book after Why Evolution Is True. It, obviously, deals with the methodological incompatibility of science and religion. Someone can be both religious and a scientist but that doesn’t mean the ideas are compatible. There are also, for example, judges that take bribes; but that doesn’t mean that that’s compatible with being a judge. Since I’ve been reading his blog (He insists it’s not a blog.) for years and other pieces on the topic, I doubt there will be much new. Still, it should be interesting and it’s nice to have everything succinctly put together.

Schönbrunn Tiergarten

A few weeks ago, some members of my lab planned a trip to the Schönbrunn Tiergarten (Schönbrunn Zoo) in Vienna, the oldest zoo in the world, and I went with them. In this post I’ll just share some of the better photos from the day. I should also note that I have not forgotten that zoos are seldom ideal. I take some solace in that, according to Wikipedia:

Today, Tiergarten Schönbrunn is considered and regards itself as a scientifically administered zoo which sees its main purpose as a centre for species conservation and general nature conservation as well as in the fulfillment of the education mandate given to it by the legislation.

Regarding that, I did, from time to time, keep an eye out for environmental enrichments. Obviously a brief visit is not going to give a great overview but I did see enrichment in some enclosures, so I assume that such considerations are taken into account. Continue reading

Some programming to share

I haven’t posted here much as my supervisor is a bit of a workaholic and its been tough to find time to do everything that needs to be done and engaging in healthy non-work activities. However, I have permission from my supervisor to share something from my work, a set of three simple scripts I wrote. All these scripts run in the UNIX shell.

They’re probably not the most efficient way to do things but, considering I only started to learn any programming last year, I’m rather proud of them. (I’m not counting some basic HTML or fiddling around with the OHRRPGCE plotscripting language which I used to do a few years ago.) You can find them here on Github.

For these to work I already had the correctly formatted protein sequences and gene groupings. The first script “aligningproteinfamilies” went through the list of groups and used T-Coffee to align those proteins. That result came out in Clustal format which I found tricky to work with, so I wrote “reformatclustal” to pull out only the bits that were important to me; the actual sequence and the consensus scoring. In the new format it was easier to look for a perfect alignment, find the position in the line and then extract the amino acid sequence corresponding to that position with “maxconslenresultv2.”

Quicklinks: Animals and religion

You might recall that, last year, I spoke about some free on-line educational tools I was dabbling with. I now want to recommend that anyone who has some sort of contact with animals, whether through work, having a pet or just eating meat, take the Animal Behaviour and Welfare course offered by The University of Edinburgh. I found it to be very engaging and an excellent introduction into a subject which affects most of us. It’s a welfare approach so sometimes it has its flaws, seeking to maximise welfare when one might rather stop the practice altogether, but it is science-based and doesn’t push a specific view. For example, they mention that cats kept indoors will be safer and have medical care but have welfare concerns about boredom and lack of choice. Stray animals benefit from free choices but have welfare challenges like being attacked by humans. In addition, there is a lot of extra information available. I didn’t have the time to go through it all but aside from the standard lectures there are extra recorded interviews and Google Hangouts as well as links to books and scientific articles which could be of interest.

At the end of last year, I stopped following Pharyngula, which had been one of my original inspirations for blogging, because I no longer considered PZ Myers to be a good model for rational thought. I felt kinda satisfied to now read that Atheist Ireland has (more symbolically than anything else) publicly dissociated from him. Their complaint is largely based on his “hurtful and dehumanising, hateful and violent, unjust and defamatory rhetoric.” It’s hard to fault them there. He always was less polite than many other writers but there are times when that can be justified and other times when it’s extraneous. His usage was mostly belonged to the latter category.

Lastly, a member of Mensa South Africa posted a link to this infographic on the group’s Facebook feed. It lists 439 topics where Bible verses contradict one another. In places it will no doubt be argued that it’s just semantics and interpretation but others are clear-cut contradictions. For example, regarding the death of Judas, Matthew 27:5 says:

So Judas threw the money into the temple and left. Then he went away and hanged himself.

While Acts 1:18 says:

With the payment he received for his wickedness, Judas bought a field; there he fell headlong, his body burst open and all his intestines spilled out.

Steam support sucks

For those that don’t know, Steam is Valve Corporation’s digital distribution software that’s used for buying, managing and playing games online. If you want to play any modern games these days (at least legal copies), it’s pretty much essential software. However, the customer service and support is almost completely non-existent.

Take this scenario. You get given a present but the item is incorrect; perhaps it’s a book that you’ve already got or maybe it’s a PS4 version of a game when you have an X-Box. You go back to the shop where it was bought, explain the situation and exchange it for something else or the correct version. Some shops might require a receipt but you’d struggle to find one that wouldn’t be happy to do the exchange and keep a customer happy. Continue reading