Problems with circumcision and HIV/AIDS

When I blogged about the German court ruling on circumcision I said that there was evidence that circumcision reduced the risk of HIV/AIDS infection. I may have been a bit premature.

I haven’t read the papers but had my own problem with the idea. If you tell someone it will reduce their risk then they’re more likely to take the risk. After my post I heard from a colleague of mine who has read the paper that at least one of the trials was flawed because those undergoing circumcision where educated on safe sex practices while the others were not. This means they weren’t equal from the start.

Both those issues and more are brought up in this blog post from an Oxford ethicist. In short the studies are described as:

Poorly conducted experiments with dubious results presented in an outrageously misleading fashion.

6 thoughts on “Problems with circumcision and HIV/AIDS

  1. Pingback: Faculty bioethics day 2/2 | Evidence & Reason

  2. Pingback: Africa: Time for a Circumcision-Driven HIV Policy in Africa? · Global Voices

  3. Pingback: Afrika: Ist es Zeit für eine beschneidungsbetonte HIV-Politik? · Global Voices auf Deutsch

  4. Pingback: El Despertador Americano | África: ¿Es momento de una política de circuncisión masculina …

  5. Pingback: أفريقيا: هل حان الوقت لوضع سياسة لختان الذكور تحمي من الإيدز؟ · Global Voices الأصوات العالمية

  6. Pingback: Afrika: Dags för HIV-policy baserad på manlig omskärelse? · Global Voices på svenska

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s